There is literally no argument you could make to put Peyton Manning in the top 10 discussion. He's the biggest Choke in NFL history; He wasted teams that were loaded. He's a HoFer (Hall of Famer), but he is not a top 10-15 QBs.
I'm tired of seeing people call this man the "GOAT" of anything other than insurance commercials and stand up comedy. Nearly every post season he stood in the pocket and choked-up INTs with HoFers on Offense and Pro Bowlers on defense. This man, this Mike and Ike head nigga, was terrible. The had to give him 5 MVPs - three of them he didn't deserve - to prevent him from being turned into a laughing stock. He's the best standup comedian of all time. Brady, Unitas and Marino are better than this nigga. Terry Bradshaw is better than this man. How can you possibly disagree? Superbowl 48 and Superbowl 50 prove this for me. He even choked away a Superbowl against Drew Brees (https://youtu.be/JM6I7AjCFAY
HIS only win in the in the Superbowl is due to his defense shutting out Rex Grossman. He has the record for most INTs for rookie. He's 9-15 agaisnt his rival. The NFL instituted the passing league of him to be more "successful." He has the record for the most one and dones and playoff loses. He choked with no excuse. He can't eat dinner without choking twice. He's a meme. Elway and the crackhead Colts owner fell for it.
Top 10 All Time:
10. Bart Star/Bradshaw
There is no debate anymore. Really there never was.